Independent nonprofit. Not affiliated with, endorsed by, or part of the Library of Congress.

Independent oversight for the nation’s cultural collections

Who watches the world’s largest library?

The Library of Congress spends public money on irreplaceable manuscripts. When one of its own scholars reported overpayment and mold in the vaults, he was dismissed — and the decision upholding his dismissal counted those reports as disruptive behavior. The law Congress wrote for itself gives its employees no comparable whistleblower protection. We exist so the next report does not disappear.

1995Congress applied federal workplace laws to itself — but left out whistleblower protection.
7 yearsOur founder’s work at the Library before his dismissal, with no written criticism of his work on record.
No. 2025-1657Affirmed by the Federal Circuit on Nov. 10, 2026, in a one-word judgment.
NextA petition to the U.S. Supreme Court is in preparation. Nothing has been filed yet.

The case

Reports of waste, counted as “disruption.”

What the record shows. Dr. Ilya Dines told his managers, and later the Library’s Inspector General, that the Library was overpaying for manuscripts and that rare items were being damaged in storage. The hearing officer who upheld his dismissal listed his repeated raising of those concerns among the conduct the Library relied on, alongside other grounds.

The Library’s position. His concerns were outside his duties, he was told to stop raising them with management, and his dismissal rested on legitimate reasons, including a finding that he gave an untrue account of a September 2023 meeting.

His argument. Reports of waste cannot lawfully be counted as grounds for dismissal — and if the Congressional Accountability Act allows it, Congress’s exemption of its own workforce from whistleblower protection raises a constitutional question.

“…the Claimant repeatedly raised concerns about the Respondent’s acquisition processes… The Claimant escalated these issues to the senior managers in the entire Law Library.” Merits Hearing Officer’s decision, OCWR No. 23-LC-44, July 8, 2024, p. 18

Read the petition and every decision in full → [link to documents page]

  1. 2015
    Kluge Fellow at the Library of Congress.
  2. 2017 – 2022
    Contractor describing the Library’s medieval manuscripts.
  3. Nov. 2022
    Appointed Librarian (Codicology Specialist) after a competitive selection.
  4. Spring – summer 2023
    Reports overpayment, mold and digitization problems to his chain of supervision.
  5. Aug. 2023
    Takes acquisition concerns to the Inspector General and the Library’s General Counsel.
  6. Sept. 20, 2023
    Dismissed.
  7. 2024 – 2025
    OCWR hearing and Board review. Claims rejected.
  8. Nov. 10, 2026
    Federal Circuit affirms without opinion.
  9. Next
    Petition to the U.S. Supreme Court — in preparation, deadline Feb. 8, 2027.

The gap

Same report. Different branch. No protection.

The Office of Congressional Workplace Rights has asked Congress for more than a decade to give its employees whistleblower protections comparable to the rest of the federal workforce. It has not happened.

Executive branch

An agency employee reports a gross waste of funds

  • Protected by the Whistleblower Protection Act
  • If the report contributed to a firing, the agency must prove by clear and convincing evidence it would have fired anyway
  • Independent channels: Office of Special Counsel, Merit Systems Protection Board
Legislative branch

A Library of Congress employee reports the same thing

  • No comparable general whistleblower protection
  • The report itself may be counted as “disruptive behavior”
  • Protection exists only if the complaint also concerns discrimination covered by the Congressional Accountability Act

Our work

Watching how a national treasure is bought and kept.

Acquisitions audit

We compare what the Library pays for manuscripts and rare books with auction and dealer records, and publish the results.

Preservation watch

We track conservation, storage and inspection practice for rare collections against the standards of the world’s great libraries.

People who speak up

Plain guidance for legislative-branch staff on the channels that exist — the Inspector General, OCWR — and their limits. We cannot protect anyone from dismissal; we can tell them what the law does and does not do.

Closing the gap

Research and testimony for the congressional committees that oversee the Library, and for whistleblower protection in the legislative branch.

[Portrait of Dr. Ilya Dines]

Founder & Executive Director

Dr. Ilya Dines

A historian of medieval manuscripts who spent seven years describing the Library of Congress’s collections. He reads more than a dozen languages, from Latin and Greek to Syriac and Old Occitan, and has worked at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, the University of Cologne and the University of Cambridge.

Ph.D., summa cum laude, Hebrew University Kluge Fellow, Library of Congress, 2015 Westminster Bestiary (Siloé, 2019) Apocalyptic Cartography (Brill, 2015)

Board of directors: [three names, affiliations] · Advisory council: [names]

Membership

Join the people watching the vaults.

Membership opens once the organization is incorporated.

Student & Librarian

$25 / year
  • The monthly dispatch
  • Members’ briefings on each new report
  • Reduced fees for courses and events
Become a member

Member

$60 / year
  • Everything in Student & Librarian
  • Invitations to public briefings
  • Early access to research reports
Become a member

Patron

$250 / year
  • Everything in Member
  • A seat at the annual members’ meeting
  • Thanks in the annual report
Become a patron

LOC Watchdog accepts no funds from manuscript dealers, auction houses or any party to the Library’s acquisitions. Donations and dues are not used to pay for any individual’s private litigation.

Courses · planned

Learn to care for the old books.

I

Keeping a rare book alive

Storage, boxes, humidity and mold inspection for small libraries, parishes and private collections. Planned: online, 4 weeks.

II

Introduction to codicology

How a medieval book was made, and how to read its parchment, quires, bindings and marginalia. Planned: online, 6 weeks.

III

Buying manuscripts without overpaying

Dating, provenance and dealer descriptions: what to check before an institution signs. Planned: online, 3 weeks.

Dates and fees will be announced to subscribers first.

Shop · planned

Beasts from the margins.

Every purchase funds our work. Designs drawn from public-domain medieval bestiaries.

The Pelican tote[$ price]
Wakeful Lion mug[$ price]
Marginalia notebook[$ price]
Bestiary calendar 2027[$ price]

The monthly dispatch

One document. One finding. Once a month.

Court filings, Inspector General reports, budget lines and auction records — read for you by people who know manuscripts.